Big Apple Collects

Cleveland Indians Cards

Browse 14 Cleveland Indians trading cards from 1983–2021, led by C.C. Sabathia (1 card), Franmil Reyes (1 card) and Asdrubal Cabrera (1 card). The most valuable Cleveland Indians card we track is the Charles Nagy #466 1991 Topps at $1.

Charles Nagy 1991 Topps #466 baseball card - Front

Charles Nagy

1991 Topps Baseball

Miguel Dilone 1983 Fleer #405 baseball card - Front

Miguel Dilone

1983 Fleer Baseball

Carlos Baerga 1996 Sportflix #70 baseball card - Front

Carlos Baerga

1996 Pinnacle Sportflix Baseball

Eddie Murray 1996 Studio #96 baseball card - Front

Eddie Murray

1996 Donruss Studio Baseball

Orel Hershiser 1996 Pinnacle #248 baseball card - Front

Orel Hershiser

1996 Pinnacle Baseball

Carlos Santana 2010 Topps Chrome #198 Green Refractors baseball rookie card - Front

Carlos Santana

Green Refractors

2010 Topps Chrome Baseball

Kenny Lofton 1995 Donruss #371 baseball card - Front

Kenny Lofton

1995 Donruss Baseball

Francisco Lindor 2018 Panini Chronicles #17 Status baseball card - Front

Francisco Lindor

Status

2018 Panini Chronicles Baseball

Tom Candiotti 1989 Upper Deck #470 baseball card - Front

Tom Candiotti

1989 Upper Deck Baseball

Slider 2013 Topps Opening Day #M-24 Mascots baseball card - Front

Slider

Mascots

2013 Topps Opening Day Baseball

Jordan Luplow 2020 Topps #565 baseball card - Front

Jordan Luplow

2020 Topps Baseball

Franmil Reyes 2021 Topps #341 Royal Blue baseball card - Front

Franmil Reyes

Royal Blue

2021 Topps Baseball

C.C. Sabathia 2002 Donruss Diamond Kings #40 baseball card - Front

C.C. Sabathia

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings Baseball

Asdrubal Cabrera 2012 Topps #130 Red baseball card - Front

Asdrubal Cabrera

Red

2012 Topps Baseball